Kadokawa Causes Cancellation of Suzumiya Haruhi Doujin Game

GarbledOne's picture

Japanese doujin circle souvenier circ. has ceased distribution of their Suzumiya Haruhi doujin game titled "The Fierce Fighting of Haruhi Suzumiya" (「涼宮ハルヒの激闘」) due to a request from Kadokawa Shoten.

According to Anime News Network, Kadokawa has requested that the game creators cease the distribution of their Dynasty Warrior-esque game. The game was marketed as a full on 3D brawler a la Dynasty Warriors featuring the members of the SOS Brigade. Kadokawa owns the rights to all usage of the Melancholy of Suzumiya Haruhi properties as it is the publisher of the original novel series by Tanigawa Nagaru and the distributor of both the adventure game for PS2 and the upcoming Wii title.
A screen from the unreleased gameA screen from the unreleased game

This is not a first for companies administering cease and desists to fan circles. Kadokawa had previously requested that another doujin circle cease the distribution of their Keroro Gunsou puzzle game "Otoshimasu" in 2004 and Crypton Future Media just recently requested a stop on unofficial dakimakuras (DarkMirage) produced by a similar fan group.

While they are perfectly within their rights to issue these C&D's, should they be doing it? While doujinshi in general is clearly copyright violation, it has generally been looked upon as a sort of grassroots method of advertisements. When Crypton requested the cessation of the dakimakuras, fans worldwide called out because the only reason why Hatsune Miku gained her popularity was due to the incredible fan support on Nico Nico Video and other such sites. In a way, attacking the fan made content seems like attacking the fans themselves. On the other hand, should they allow this to happen, their property may get diluted and they may lose their copyright.

So what side of the fence are all of you on?

Comments

Games:

This is hard to believe. So is the game gone for good then?

nintendo wii sale:

Too bad about the cease and desist. I guess if I owned the rights, I wouldn't want the circulation...but that could be bad for pr though, huh? Well, this one is a toughy. Thanks for the post.

James @ speed up vista:

Shame, looks like a lot of fun. What platform was it out for?

GarbledOne:

@James:
This was out for the PC. Independently developed doujin games are usually developed for the PC, unless it's that fantasy elf h-game for the DS...

James @ how to overclock cpu:

Thanks

nes for sale:

Surprisingly, I played this game and it was good. Too bad it got killed by the copyright owners.

Property For Sale Portugal:

Its a shame the game got canceled! It looks fun!

Property:

This reminds me of the Scrabulous VS Hasbro case in facebook. Rights owner are basically destroying a potential revenue source and causing the irks of their fan base by sending out such cease-and-desist order. What a bad move!

Dieta:

Its specially silly because the game was as good as finished!

Cheap Nintendo Wii:

I love anime and in fact I played a small role in a DVD extra in last years Pokemon Ranger and the Temple of the Sea. That was a lot of fun.

Anonymous:

about this game, although it is sad that no updates or anything will ever come out, the game IS still out there somewhere
torrents, obscure forums, etc.

and yes, if your computer is good enough, the game is a lot of fun XD